How accurate is this Etsy vs Shopify calculator?

The calculator uses the latest published fee structures from both platforms. Etsy fees include listing ($0.20), transaction (6.5%), payment processing (3.4% + $0.20), and optional Offsite Ads (15%). Shopify fees include monthly subscription and payment processing (2.9%–2.4% + $0.30 depending on plan). Results are estimates — actual fees may vary slightly based on your specific setup.

When does Shopify become cheaper than Etsy?

It depends on your price point and volume. Generally, once you exceed ~50 orders per month, Shopify's flat monthly fee becomes more cost-effective than Etsy's per-transaction fees. The breakeven analysis in this calculator shows you the exact crossover point for your specific products.

Does this include Etsy Offsite Ads fees?

Yes, you can toggle Offsite Ads on or off. Etsy charges 15% on sales generated through their offsite advertising program. Sellers earning over $10,000/year are automatically enrolled and cannot opt out.

What about Shopify apps — aren't those extra costs?

This calculator covers platform fees only. Shopify apps are additional costs, but many essential features (like product customization with Podifai) offer free plans. Factor in any app costs when making your final decision.

Can I sell on both Etsy and Shopify?

Absolutely. Many successful sellers use Etsy for discovery and Shopify as their primary store. Etsy brings marketplace traffic, while Shopify gives you full brand control and higher margins at scale.

Is this calculator free to use?

Yes, 100% free. No signup, no email required. Use it as many times as you need to compare different product scenarios.

What Shopify plan should I choose?

For most small to medium sellers, the Basic plan ($39/month) is sufficient. Upgrade to Shopify ($105/month) when you need better payment processing rates (2.6% vs 2.9%) and your volume justifies the savings. Advanced ($399/month) is for high-volume stores.

Does Etsy charge fees on shipping?

Yes, Etsy's 6.5% transaction fee applies to the total order amount including shipping. This calculator factors in shipping costs when calculating Etsy fees.

Free — No Signup Required

Etsy vs Shopify Fee Calculator

Compare platform fees side by side and find which marketplace is more profitable for your products. Updated for 2026 rates.

Enter Your Product Details

Product Price(per item)

Cost Per Unit(production/purchase cost)

Monthly Sales(estimated units per month)

Shipping Charge(optional)

Etsy Options

Etsy Plus Subscription ($10/month)Enable Offsite Ads (15% ad fee)

Shopify Plan

Excellent profit margin (52.0%) — both platforms are worth considering

Quick Summary:

Monthly Revenue: $1250.00

Monthly Cost: $600.00

Gross Profit: $650.00

Profit Margin: 52.0%

Shopify saves you more$53.50/mo · $642.00/yr

Etsy

$506.25/mo · 40.5% margin

Revenue

$1,250.00

Costs

$600.00

Gross

$650.00

Fees

-$143.75

Listing$10.00

Transaction$81.25

Processing$52.50

ShopifyBest Value

$559.75/mo · 44.8% margin

Revenue

$1,250.00

Costs

$600.00

Gross

$650.00

Fees

-$90.25

Processing$51.25

Subscription$39.00

Visual Comparison

Break-Even

Shopify becomes more profitable than Etsy at 22 sales/month. You're currently at 50 sales/month.

Boost Your Shopify Profits

Podifai's product customization can increase AOV by 20–30% — let customers personalize products with text, images, or designs.

Try Podifai Free →

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything you need to know about comparing Etsy and Shopify costs.

Etsy vs Shopify Fee Calculator

Enter Your Product Details

Etsy Options

Shopify Plan

Visual Comparison

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Guides

Shopify vs Etsy: The Complete Seller's Guide

Best Shopify App for Product Customization (2026)

Launch a Custom Product Line on Shopify in 2026

Product Description Generator